The Porsche 718 Cayman S is a highly sought-after sports car, praised for its handling and performance. But what’s it like to own one daily? This review from a former 2018 Cayman S 6MT owner, originally shared in a car forum, offers a candid perspective, highlighting both the exhilarating highs and the frustrating lows. This owner previously drove a BMW F80 and opted for the Cayman S with every performance option available, essentially creating a pre-GTS model.
The Good: Precision and Performance on Point
This owner raved about the Cayman S’s exceptional driving experience. The 6-speed manual transmission’s shifter was a standout feature, setting a new benchmark and making the BMW’s shifter feel subpar in comparison. This experience led the owner to exclusively consider DCT BMWs in the future.
The Cayman S also delivered with a perfect seating position, contributing to the overall driver-focused feel. The steering was precise and responsive, further enhancing the car’s connection to the road. The powerful engine and well-tuned powerband made for a quick and engaging drive, solidifying the Cayman S as a true driver’s car.
The Bad: Engine Noise and Other Frustrations
Despite the exhilarating performance, several aspects of the Cayman S fell short of expectations. The engine sound was a major disappointment. Described as resembling an air-cooled VW bus at idle and a lumpy Subaru at other times, it lacked the character and sporty growl expected from a Porsche. Only at full throttle near redline did the engine deliver a satisfying sound.
The gearing also drew criticism. First and second gear ratios were considered excessively long, with second gear reaching 80 mph. While acknowledging the benefits for track and autocross, the owner felt shorter gearing would make the car more enjoyable for everyday driving.
Other issues included the parking brake’s design and functionality, the less intuitive infotainment system compared to BMW’s, and the limited aftermarket parts availability. This lack of customization options contrasted sharply with the vast aftermarket support for BMWs. The owner valued the vibrant modding community and the ability to personalize their car, something that felt lacking with the Porsche.
Conclusion: A Mixed Bag for the Porsche Enthusiast
The Porsche 718 Cayman S offers an exceptional driving experience with its precise handling, responsive steering, and powerful engine. However, the underwhelming engine sound, long gear ratios, and limited aftermarket support detract from the overall ownership experience. This owner ultimately returned to BMW, highlighting the importance of personal preferences in choosing the right sports car. This review underscores the value of online forums like Porsche 718 Forums for gathering real-world owner experiences and insights before making a purchase decision.
